
ChatGPT Gets a Third of Black Friday Prices Wrong
Core dna asked ChatGPT where 20 Black Friday products were cheapest, twice each. 13 of 38 quoted prices were wrong. Fix it before November 27.
Ask ChatGPT where to buy a KitchenAid Artisan stand mixer in the United States right now and it may send you to Best Buy at $219.99. Best Buy was charging $349.99 that day. The $219.99 belonged to a refurbished bowl-lift mixer listed on the same Best Buy page. ChatGPT called it the genuine Artisan.
Core dna ran the test on November 4, 2026: 20 popular Black Friday products, the same question twice each, every recommended store checked against its own website except three the study could not verify the same way. When ChatGPT recommended an NRF Top 100 retailer, the price was wrong 13 times out of 38. Seven were too low, two too high, and four quoted a marketplace seller's price as the store's own.
Adobe expects AI traffic to US retail sites to rise 130% year over year this holiday season, with Black Friday up 95% year over year. That forecast counts shoppers clicking through, not what they were told first. Treat the cheapest-price answer as a guess that needs checking.
The test, in numbers
A price counted as right only if it was within $1 of the store's own price for the exact item. Here are the five largest gaps:
| Product and store | ChatGPT said | The store charged | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|
| Xbox Series X (digital edition), Walmart | $587.00 | $797.00 | $210, or 26% |
| KitchenAid Artisan, Best Buy | $219.99 | $349.99 | $130, or 37% |
| Bose QuietComfort Ultra Earbuds, Best Buy | $229.00 | $299.00 | $70, or 23% |
| Kindle Paperwhite, Amazon | $149.99 | $199.99 | $50, or 25% |
| LG 65-inch C6 OLED, Amazon | $1,349.99 | $1,399.99 | $50, or 4% |
The Kindle gap came from an Amazon Visa offer: $149.99 only upon card approval, while Amazon's price was $199.99.
Best Buy took the worst of it: named in 33 answers, recommended in 13, 6 of 12 checkable recommendations wrong. Target was named in 25 answers and recommended in none, usually because its price sat a cent above the winner: the LEGO Orchid at $39.99 against Walmart's $39.98.
Nearly half the wrong prices started on the retailers' own pages
Six of the 13 wrong prices started on the retailer's own website. ChatGPT reads your product page, the marketplace listings on your site, your feed, and the deal sites that copy your prices.
Half of all 184 quoted prices came from comparison sites and price trackers, and only 24% came from the retailer's own website. Both Oura Ring answers opened with eBay at 'currently $267', a tracker's 90-day low read as today's price, when the cheapest new listing that day was $309.98.
Wrong answers also carried confident labels: best verified price, cheapest confirmed price, verified on November 4, 2026. A verified label does not mean the price was checked against the store that day.
Six links in the test came through a retailer's own product feed to ChatGPT, and five quoted the right price. That makes your feed the first thing to check.
Ask again and the answer changes
For 11 of the 20 products, asking the same question in a new chat gave a different store or price. The second answers were more accurate, with 5 wrong out of 20 against 8 out of 18 the first time. They fixed four answers and broke one: the Switch 2 bundle went from $549 to $539, an international version from a marketplace seller. Nine products held their answer across both asks, and three held on a wrong answer.
I measure AI answers the way I measure citations. I ask the same question three times, in new chats, on a free account, logged in and out, and I record the store, price, source, and ad every time. One sample tells you what ChatGPT said once.
The ad under the answer is sometimes more accurate than the answer
In Core dna's test, 37 of the 40 answers carried an ad underneath. OpenAI says ads do not influence the answers ChatGPT gives. It began testing ads in the US in February 2026 and opened self-serve buying on May 5.
Both JBL Flip 7 answers sent shoppers to Best Buy at a price it was not offering: $117.29 from a marketplace seller, then a $99.43 listing that could not be bought. Both times, Best Buy's own ad below the answer showed the speaker at $129.95, its real price. Under both Sony WH-1000XM6 answers it went the other way: the answer had Best Buy right at $378, while the carousel underneath showed $458.
You cannot pay to correct the answer, but you can pay to put your real price directly under it. If your ad shows a comparison value or an old price, you pay to show a second wrong one. Capital One Shopping advertised under 12 of the 40 answers. Rivals can buy the same space: SharkNinja under both Dyson answers, Temu under the Bose earbuds.
AI-referred shoppers buy. In Marie Haynes' study of 100 sites, ChatGPT sent 0.62% of Google's organic sessions but, among the 55 sites tracking conversions, converted at 13.8% against 3.02% for Google organic. A wrong price in front of those shoppers is a sale sent to the wrong store.
The check to run this week
Core dna's timeline gives retailers until November 20 to brief deals with end dates and check their ChatGPT ads, and until November 27 to check feeds, listings, and AI answers once sale prices are live. Run the baseline now, on 10 to 20 hero products, and score each one on Core dna's six measures:
| Measure | What it tells you | How to count it |
|---|---|---|
| Named rate | How often you appear | Answers naming you / answers asked |
| Recommended rate | How often you are the store sent to | Answers recommending you / answers asked |
| Price accuracy | Whether the quoted price is what you charge | Correct prices for you / prices quoted for you |
| Source mix | Where the answer got your price | Product page, marketplace listing, feed, tracker, article |
| Landing page | Where the link takes the shopper | Your product page, a search page, another site |
| Ad and panel | Whether the ad shows your price | Matches / ads and panels seen |
Ask each product three times in new chats and click through from inside the answer. Then fix what the baseline finds: name the seller and condition for every other offer on the page, in each Offer's seller, itemCondition, and availability fields. Put the exact model, generation, size, and bundle in the title and the product data. Send the same details in your feed and update prices when they change. Put offer terms next to the price and date every deal you brief out.
The Podqi study I covered on November 15 found risky stores in 9% of AI shopping answers.
What price does ChatGPT quote for your best-selling product right now, and does it match the price on your site?

About the author
Dalin de Graff is a digital marketing expert based in Winnipeg, Canada, with 9 years of experience across SEO, GEO, and AI search. At First Rank, he built the agency's GEO practice and leads its work on AI search and LLM visibility. His results include +311% organic clicks, +300% calls, and +98% AI search traffic in 30 days. He writes about search, AI, and marketing at dalindegraff.com.